• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Don Carmelo's Pizzeria: Authentic Italian Pizza in Omaha

At Don Carmelo's Pizzeria, the spirit of Italian cuisine thrives in the heart of Omaha. Established in 1958, this neighborhood gem has become a beloved destination for pizza lovers. With a menu highlighting New York-style pies, delicious hoagies, and fresh salads, each dish reflects a commitment to quality and flavor. The friendly staff and welcoming atmosphere make it ideal for families and casual dining. Guests rave about the generous portions and unique toppings, wrapped in a cozy setting that encourages community. Whether dining in or enjoying takeout, Don Carmelo's is where tradition meets taste, promising an unforgettable Italian experience.

Don Carmelo's Pizzeria at a glance

  • Address 10821 Prairie Brook Rd, Omaha, NE 68144
  • Phone (402) 933-3190
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant , Italian restaurant .
  • Popular for Popular for lunch , Popular for dinner , Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Don Carmelo's Pizzeria: Reviews & Ratings

Letz Getreal
5

Order a pizza. I use the New York thin crust created my own toppings of bacon chicken basil pesto for the base feta cheese and roasted red peppers. I would say it would be a good addition to put some bee sting honey drizzle over the top. Pizza seems to be made fresh and in-house crust is very light crispy and airy. I had a really good buttery flavor and chewiness. The only reason I put atmosphere and service as a 4 star is because you still have to do some self-service. I do like the booths, they were pretty clean.

Don Dotson
5

Great pizza a staple in the community. If you have been there get their pizza. Way better than those franchise guys.

KC McD
5

My favorite pizza in Omaha. Walk in and order at the counter. Let them know if it is takeout. Seat yourself for diner in, after you order. They will bring out your food, plates, silverware when they bring your food. There are menus on the table in front of the cash register and the most popular items overhead. Sometimes the owner is there making the pizzas and those are extra good. Not sure why, they just are. Mostly, I see him at the Elkhorn location. This is definitely fold the slice NY pizza. Highly recommend. Rockbrook location closed Mondays at the time of this review.

Connor Kreikemeier
5

Great place to eat! My first time here and I thoroughly enjoyed it. The lady who took our was really nice as well.

Steve Tafolla
4

We are lucky to live near Don Carmelo’s Pizza. We usually get our food to go. The store is small but has a number of comfortable tables. The pizza is good plus they have a number of other good choices. Service is great!

Morgan H.
5

Don Carmelo's Pizzeria for the first time last night to celebrate National Pizza Day! And OMG. Don Carmelo’s just made it into my top 5 pizza joints in Omaha. I’m so sad I didn’t try it sooner. I feel like you don’t hear enough about this delicious New York style pizza and that definitely needs to change! Plus they had amazing customer service and a quick turnaround on our order despite it being a busy night for orders for National Pizza Day. Just added it to our regular rotation.

Mari Lee
5

We requested a heart shaped pizza for our anniversary and it was exactly what we were expecting! Love that this is a local, family owned restaurant. Our experience exceeded our expectations, the food and service is always top notch!!!

Nicholas Dembinski
5

Took my son here for a late lunch after errands. I have lived up the road for 6 years and never knew about this place!! I had the antipasta salad and my son and I had a pepperoni pizza. Salad was a great fresh start to the meal. The pickled peppers were awesome. As for the pizza, the crust was crisp and just enough doughy chew in it while is was that perfect pliable texture under the toppings. This reminds me a lot of the pizza you can get in the north east of the country. Also this is EXACTLY how I remember pizza tasting when I was a kid. And I mean that in the best way possible. Love this place and plan to become a regular.

Location

  • Don Carmelo's Pizzeria
    Don Carmelo's Pizzeria
    10821 Prairie Brook Rd, Omaha, NE 68144 Hotline: (402) 933-3190

Welcome to Don Carmelo's Pizzeria, an esteemed gem nestled in the heart of Omaha, NE, specifically at 10821 Prairie Brook Rd. This iconic establishment has been serving delicious New York-style pizza since 1958. When you step into Don Carmelo's, you’re not just entering a restaurant; you are diving into a rich history of culinary excellence paired with an inviting atmosphere. This pizzeria is proudly women-owned and veteran-owned, reflecting a commitment to community and service.

Don Carmelo's offers a unique blend of classic Italian flair and modern conveniences. The pizzeria caters to all, whether you’re seeking a cozy spot for family dining, a casual takeout meal, or a relaxing dinner with friends. With amenities such as outdoor seating, wheelchair accessibility, and even dog-friendly options, every guest is welcome. Patrons can enjoy the simplicity of their casual dress code, knowing they can unwind in a space that balances a quiet ambiance with the energy of shared moments.

The menu is a pizza lover’s dream. You simply cannot go wrong with the specially prepared combos, such as the New York's Finest and Meat Lover pizzas, each bursting with flavor and handcrafted from quality ingredients. Those looking for lighter options will find delight in their Veggie and Margherita selections, both priced affordably under $10.99. Beyond pizza, Don Carmelo's presents a delightful array of pasta options like Mostaciolli or Angel Hair, and hearty hoagies such as the Super Italian and Turkey Cheese. Each dish tells a story of tradition and care, delivering flavors that transport you straight to Italy.

As Gianna B. raved in her review, the pizzas are incredibly flavorful, particularly the unique blend of sausage and feta that elevates the experience. And let’s not forget the toasted hoagies, which have a perfect balance of ingredients wrapped in freshly baked bread. It’s these little details that make Don Carmelo's shine.

Not only is the food notable, but the service is equally commendable. Regulars have praised the staff's friendliness and attentiveness, often highlighting how they remember special requests like extra cheese or crushed red pepper. This attentiveness extends to the overall customer experience, with quick service for takeout making it a hassle-free option for busy families or individuals.

Don Carmelo's isn’t just a place to eat; it's a place to enjoy and celebrate. With features like happy hour specials, onsite parking, and free Wi-Fi, it caters to every kind of dining need. Whether you are enjoying a slice with friends while watching a game or having a heartfelt conversation in a cozy booth, this pizzeria remains a cherished part of the Omaha dining landscape.

In conclusion, if you're looking for an authentic pizza experience that embodies taste, warmth, and a touch of nostalgia, make your way to Don Carmelo's Pizzeria. With their commitment to quality and service, they promise to nail it every time, just like they have for over 60 years.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards